Marg Gardiner
Running for council · IncumbentCouncillor since 2022, running again.
marggardiner.caMany people want to run the city, but not all would run it well.
See who we believe is worth your support and who isn't and why - with a deep dive on its own page.
All six were also endorsed by the Victoria Firefighters union, IAFF Local 730, on September 23, as was Jason Heit, whom we have not assessed yet. What the firefighters asked for.
Councillor since 2022, running again.
marggardiner.ca
Councillor since 2022, running again.
votestephenhammond.ca
Standing for council for the first time.
arthurmcinnis.ca
Standing for council for the first time.
karenrothe.ca
Standing for council for the first time.
wendybowkett.ca
Standing for council for the first time.
melissacseszko.caTheir record is on our home page, and a vote for change does not go to any of them.
Councillor since 2022, running again.
mattdell.caCouncillor since 2022, running again.
His re-election announcementCouncillor since 2022, running again.
kristaloughton.caCouncillor since 2022, running again.
victoriaforall.caCouncillor since 2022, running again.
davethompsonvictoria.caEndorsed, praised or running on a slate with a Gang of 5 councillor. The details are under "Who is the Gang of 5?" below.
Standing for council for the first time.
victoriaforall.caStanding for council for the first time.
bellalee.caStanding for council for the first time.
jacksandor.caWe have not looked closely at these seven yet, and we have not ruled them out.
No campaign website located yet.
No campaign website located yet.
No campaign website located yet.
Eight people are running for mayor. We are voting for Bruce McGuigan, and here is why. One of them, Marianne Alto, votes with the Gang of 5 and we do not support her.
No campaign website located yet.
No campaign website located yet.
No campaign website located yet.
No campaign website located yet.
No campaign website located yet.
"Gang of 5" is the name residents use for the five sitting councillors who vote as a bloc on the big decisions documented on our home page:
Mayor Marianne Alto votes with the Gang of 5 on most of these decisions. That gives it six votes out of nine. The OCP, the budget increases, the land purchases and the social services policy all passed that way.
The Gang of 5 is busy in this election too. Dave Thompson has endorsed Jack Sandor. Matt Dell has publicly praised Bella Lee, who ran Mayor Alto's 2022 campaign. If you are deciding whether you want the current majority to carry on, it helps to know which new candidates it is backing.
Councillor Kim is running under the Victoria For All banner, a slate launched in August 2026 with first-time candidate Peter Rose Gibbs and a school board candidate. It is the only slate with council candidates on the ballot this time, so part of the Gang of 5 is asking to be re-elected as a team rather than one by one.
Add it up and you get five sitting councillors plus three new names, Jack Sandor, Bella Lee and Peter Rose Gibbs, and all eight are on the slate the Victoria Labour Council picked in private, set out below. That is what change at city hall comes down to, because if you send the five back nothing changes, and if you elect the three they are backing nothing changes either. The other choice is to vote for people who have already shown better judgement, and we have named six.
More background, including where the nickname came from, is in the glossary.
Candidates are only half the story. Several groups back slates, endorse candidates, or spend money as registered sponsors. It helps to know who they are.
A climate advocacy group that was a registered third-party sponsor in the 2022 civic election and endorsed the Gang of 5 plus Mayor Alto. It has hired staff for the 2026 civic election and is running paid ads inviting people to fill in a survey. The responses feed follow-up emails telling people who to vote for. It is registered again for 2026.
A housing advocacy group that pushes for maximum housing supply. It was a registered sponsor in 2022 and is not on the 2026 register as of August 26. Several people in this election have ties to it: council candidate Jack Sandor is a former vice-president, and councillors Dell, Loughton and Thompson were each involved with the group before or during their time in office. Critics have documented developer involvement in its earlier days. Background reading: CRD Watch's article index.
Has endorsed candidates in Greater Victoria for many years and was a registered third-party sponsor in 2022, endorsing the Gang of 5 plus Mayor Alto. At a council meeting, Councillor Susan Kim said labour-council-endorsed candidates had committed to opposing public-private partnerships.
For 2026 its own website says the endorsement interviews are complete and that successful candidates will be contacted, but it does not publish the list. Councillor Matt Dell published it himself on August 18, announcing his own endorsement and then naming the rest: "Also endorsed by the Victoria Labour Council were incumbents Krista Loughton, Jeremy Caradonna, Dave Thompson and Susan Kim, and new candidates Bella Lee, Peter Gibbs and Jack Sandor."
That is eight names for the eight council seats on the ballot, chosen in private and announced before nominations have even opened. In the same post Councillor Dell commits to "completion of the new Crystal Pool and building a new main library branch downtown", which is worth reading next to our page on what the city is already spending.
A coalition of advocacy groups grading municipal candidates across the Capital Region on a letter scale from A to F, with results to be published before election day. It is a registered local elections advertising sponsor with Elections BC. It lists fourteen member organizations: Walk On Victoria, Better Island Transit, Climate Justice Victoria, Family Doctors for Saanich, Victori'us Arts, Better Transit YYJ, Homes for Living, Better Columbia, Greater Victoria Acting Together, Strong Towns Victoria, Common Horizon Victoria, Resilient Urban Systems and Habitat, Grumpy Taxpayer$ of Greater Victoria, and Defund VicPD. Two of those are groups this page profiles in their own right, Homes for Living and GVAT, so the scorecard is not being written at arm's length from the campaigns it grades. It also points visitors to Dogwood's voting pledge. Elections BC records its authorized principal official as Michael Bassili, with a Better Transit YYJ contact address, though the site itself does not say who assigns the grades. Candidates had until September 18 to answer and be graded on the site. Our view: a scorecard is only as neutral as the questions behind it, and these questions are written by groups that campaign for particular outcomes. Read the questions before you read the grades.
GVAT is one of the fourteen organizations in the Livable CRD coalition. Its own site describes it as an alliance that grew out of a faith group called Faith In Action, and says it is an affiliate of the Industrial Areas Foundation Pacific, a community organizing network registered in Washington State with affiliates in several countries. It says that in 2022 it held a Homes For All assembly during the municipal election and "gained the commitment of the candidates to meet with us annually" on its housing targets. gvat.ca
Sasha Izard has written two detailed pieces on GVAT for CRD Watch: one on its single listed staff member and her links to Homes for Living, and one on how it was formed and how it relates to the Industrial Areas Foundation. CRD Watch argues a case rather than reporting neutrally, and we link it as such. Our view: a local campaign that asks candidates for annual accountability meetings on its own targets is doing organized political work, and voters should know it exists.
A new municipal slate launched in August 2026, running Councillor Susan Kim and Peter Rose Gibbs for council and one candidate for school board. Its sign-up form identifies the organization behind it as Victoria Progressive Electors. The shared platform is doubling city investment in affordable housing, stronger protections against renoviction and demoviction, and expanded mental health and addictions crisis response. victoriaforall.ca
A cycling advocacy group and 2022 third-party sponsor, not on the 2026 register as of August 26. The city has been a generous partner: close to $250,000 went to a single season of the downtown bike valet, alongside continued spending on lane expansion. When a group advocates for spending and also campaigns in the election, voters deserve to see both halves.
Third-party sponsors must register with Elections BC and disclose what they spend. The 2026 register is published and updated as groups sign up. The version we read is dated August 26, 2026, and registration stays open until voting day, so a group missing from it today may appear tomorrow.
For deeper background on the interconnections at city hall, see BC Politics Watch.
This is what we think Victoria deserves from the people who want the job. We will measure candidates against it, and you can too.
Whomever you lean toward, these five questions separate candidates who will consult you, from candidates who will explain decisions after the fact. Bring these questions to every all-candidates meeting. Send them to every campaign email address and request answers. They are the same five on the printed Voter Guide.
Are you running and we have missed you, or is a detail above out of date? Email sustainablevictorianetwork@gmail.com and a volunteer will correct it.
Candidate list last checked on October 2, 2026 against the City of Victoria's declaration of candidates. Nominations closed on September 11, so this is the final ballot.
Get one short email when candidates answer the five questions, and when advance voting opens.